Recent Articles
Showing posts with label morality. Show all posts
Showing posts with label morality. Show all posts

Saturday, February 9, 2013

‘Zero Dark Thirty’ (2013) directed by Kathryn Bigelow, 6th February 2013

Saturday, February 9, 2013 - by londoncitynights · - 0 Comments



O cherished torturess, steely eyes glinting in a filthy room, the professional set of your jaw!  

O venerated torturess, LCD-lit flawless porcelain skin, ultra-clean ultra-smart trouser suit! 

O sweet torturess, flaxen hair falling cinematically across your mirrored shades, will your chariot bear his corpse?

O noble torturess, sacrificing youth and life to keep us safe, doing “what must be done”!

I’ll stop this bullshit right here.  And if you're wondering, yes, Zero Dark Thirty is every bit as reprehensible as you’ve heard.  Kathryn Bigelow has created a film where we sympathise with torturers.  Our heroes are men and women who practise dark arts like placing people in stress positions for prolonged periods, putting collars on people and leading them around like dogs, shoving prisoners into tiny wooden boxes, sexual humiliation, waterboarding and just plain old fashioned punching them in the face over and over again.  It’s a moral car crash of a movie, one where absolution for war crimes comes in the form of a teary close-up where we see just. what. the. personal. toll. has. been.

Jessica Chastain as Maya.
Bollocks to your "personal toll", Bigelow.  I couldn’t give a tuppenny fuck about the conflicted internal lives of your dead-eyed gang of war criminals.  The old joke rings true; a man sits miserably in the corner of a pub mumbling:
“This pub, this very pub we're just sitting in. I built it, with my own hands! But do they call me the Pubmaker? No! See the wall over there, that protects our town? I built it, with my own hands! But do they call me the Wallmaker? And the bridge, you know, that crosses our river, I built it, with my own hands! But do they call me the Bridgemaker? But I tell you man. You fuck one goat….”
The heroes of Zero Dark Thirty are these goatfuckers, irrevocably stained by their crimes against humanity.  It’s easy to be suckered into seeing the film as a moral swamp which no-one comes out of cleanly, but this is having your cake and eating it.  Zero Dark Thirty has pretensions towards journalism rather than entertainment, every cinematic choice is made with an eye to grounding the action, everything is muted, coldly realistic, oozing a confidence gained through meticulous research.  It’s one of those films that has the gumption to be a bit dull and difficult to follow because “this is how it went”. 


These cinematic and aesthetic tools are deployed with precision accuracy by Bigelow in a way that adds up to a moral justification of torture.  Now, I don’t believe Bigelow hungers to see prisoners humiliated and brutalised, I take her at her word when she says:
“(I’m) a lifelong pacifist, I support all protests against the use of torture, and, quite simply, inhumane treatment of any kind.”
But despite this she's directed a brilliant piece of PR for the CIA, a film that makes a crusading heroine out of a vicious torturer. She argues that “depiction is not endorsement”, yet the structure of the film she’s created inevitably nudges its audience towards acceptance of torture as a necessary evil.

This process begins from the opening moments.  The panicked screams of those dying in the burning World Trade Centre are played over a jet black screen.  In terms of propaganda, this is a “Why We Fight” sequence.  It sets the stakes, justifying almost every action that our heroes will take.  As far as the structure of the film goes, this makes the emotional case for revenge before we see a single photographed frame of the movie.  When we cut it’s to a CIA black site, with a terrified detainee being menaced by men in black balaclavas.  A link is thus made in our minds.  This sweaty, panicked man is responsible for the deaths we’ve just been forced to listen to.  It's crass and exploitative; the dead of 9/11 pressed into service as emotional shock troops to excuse the barbarism we’re about to see.

Real life butts into the film whenever events begin to become a bit sterile.  The action was almost literally brought home for me during the recreation of the 7/7 London bombings when the doomed bus drove past the end of my street.  The hunt has gotten a little esoteric by this point and Bigelow wants to reinforce who the ‘bad guys’ are, reminding us that the increasingly dry intelligence tactics we see actually have a purpose. 


Unfortunately, using 7/7 to show the importance of our CIA heroes’ quest is a critically flawed move.  The conclusion of the official inquiry into 7/7 found that the bombers acted independently: there was no connection with al-Qaeda and certainly none with Osama Bin Laden himself.  “The London attacks were a modest, simple affair by four seemingly normal men using the internet”.  So, not content with exploiting the final words of 9/11 victims, Bigelow now moves on to using our memories of the 52 victims of 7/7 to add emotional impact to the film.  In fact, there’s arguably more chance that the images of torture that emerged from Abu Ghraib prison and the reports of CIA “Enhanced Interrogation Techniques” influenced the bombers.

This all helps underline the importance and urgency of our hero's actions.  Zero Dark Thirty is complex and methodical film that requires you to pay attention or risk losing the thread of what’s going on, but in some regards it’s also an extremely simple one.  It’s a film about "THE GREATEST MANHUNT IN HISTORY", one noble woman’s quest to catch the bad guy of bad guys.

One of the common arguments I've seen to defend this film is to claim that Maya (Jessica Chastain) isn't a hero in the traditional sense.  This is disingenuous.  Firstly no-one can reasonably claim that she isn't the audience identification character.  In the opening scenes of the film she is as visibly shocked and disturbed by the torture happening in front of her as we presumably are.  As she toughens up and learns the simple pleasure of beating the shit out of restrained prisoners of war so, apparently must we.  We are dragged along with her on her path to moral degradation. 

As disturbing as it is to see someone becoming accustomed to sadism and consumed by obsession, I can't deny that Jessica Chastain does a damn good job in the role.  She's like Agent Scully gone bad, someone who's allowed herself to become chewed up from the inside out, as if working for the CIA hollows the humanity out of you.  Her sensible,ultra professional trouser suits betray no personality whatsoever, the fluorescent lighting she's under for much of the film accentuating her bony body.  Even the sunglasses she wears tend to make her head look disturbingly skull-like.  Maya becomes death.  The destroyer of worlds.

But for all the death imagery that swarms around her, Maya is the hero of the film.  At the mid-way point she's sliding neatly into the archetype of the rogue cop, she's a maverick, but she gets the job done.  She's inhabiting her narrative heroism fully when she's scrawling numbers on her boss's door ("she gets results you stupid chief!").  Maya, inevitably, becomes the one person who sees things clearly, confidently saying she's 100% sure that Bin Laden is in his compound when everyone else is waffling through a series of bureaucratic cliches.  By the time she's standing on a runway her hair whipping around cinematically as she awaits the delivery of Bin Laden's carcass she may as well be the reincarnation of Sarah Connor. 

Maya                                                                                           Sarah Connor
That Zero Dark Thirty uses this archetype is partly what exposes the lie that it doesn't endorse torture.  If Maya so clearly occupies the heroic narrative space, then her target  Osama Bin Laden (though never seen) becomes a straightforward narrative villain.  With the story viewed as Maya's heroic ascension, the torture in the first half of the film becomes retroactively justified.  So what of the final shot of the film, her weeping as she realises she's sacrificed so much to capture this man?  This reaction is the weight of her crimes preying upon her.  Her entire adult life has been devoted to catching this man, and now that she's stared into his dead eyes she has and is nothing.  Maya looks down at the corpse of Bin Laden, and Bin Laden stares right back up at the corpse of Maya.  But though she may have sacrificed everything, the screams of those trapped within the World Trade Centre still echo in the film.  Maya's self-sacrifice becomes noble. This was a shitty job, but someone had to do it.  By any means.  

That Zero Dark Thirty endorses torture makes it, for all its considerable technical and cinematic charms, a truly vile film.  It excuses the crimes of the CIA, allows us to view torture as a viable means of extracting information and begins to normalise it in popular culture.  This normalisation is probably the most distressing consequence of all, huge swathes of the audience walking out of the cinema tutting in liberal angst at what they've seen, but on some level accepting that it was a necessary evil.

Cinema is one of the most powerful and wide-reaching forms of media in our culture.  History and war become defined in the popular consciousness largely by how they're depicted in popular film.  Zero Dark Thirty wears its disguise of journalistic pretension so well that it's destined to become the popular version of events.  When future generations look back on the War on Terror, how Western civilisation reacted to the physical and psychological trauma of 9/11 and specifically the hunt for Osama Bin Laden, Zero Dark Thirty will be what they watch.  What will they see?  A culture that deifies torturers; that casually inflicts pain upon the desperate; that believes that the end justifies the means, no matter how horrible.   Is this what we want to be?

Saturday, May 26, 2012

'Aesop's Fables' performed by the Isango Ensemble, Hackney Empire 26th May 2012

Saturday, May 26, 2012 - by londoncitynights · - 0 Comments


Having seen 'Aesop's Fables' I've managed to 'complete the set' of the Isango Ensemble's residence at the Hackney Empire.  It's nice to be able to compare them, and I've now got a lot of respect of their versatility.  After 'La boheme' and 'the Ragged Trousered Philanthropists' this was a nice change of pace.  Both of the other productions seem to have been aimed at seasoned theatre-goers, 'Aesop's Fables' was more for children, and was cheery and upbeat.

I saw it on a hot and sunny Saturday afternoon. I have to admit that the prospect of spending a few hours of a beautiful day in a theatre was ever-so-slightly off putting.  On the way there I saw friends lounging around on the grass sipping ice cold, perspiring beers, and was sorely tempted to join them.  If this wasn't the only production I hadn't seen out of a set of three, I may have been won over by the sunshine.  So I entered the cool and dark theatre maybe slightly out of a sense of duty rather than unbridled enthusiasm.

Missing the sunshine was the least of my worries - this was in every sense of the word a sunny and happy production.  There was an atmosphere of playfulness in the performance that was absent from the seriousness of 'La boheme' and 'The Ragged Trousered Philanthropists'.  The mood throughout was enhanced by the fact that there were lots of children in the audience.  I don't really go to that many plays aimed at children, and their smiles and laughs were a big change from the self conscious clipped laughs and polite applause of the adult audience at, say La boheme.

This was a far more flamboyant show than the previous Isango productions.  The characters in those were poor, desperate and portrayed semi-realistically while the Aesop's Fables animals are essentially symbols of various impulses and positive and negative human traits.  Their symbolic representation allows for a lot of flexibility in the costuming.  Some highlights were the Rastafarian goat, the lycra-clad fitness fanatic hare and the glam-rock, futurepunk cockerel.  


My two favourites, which stood out for sheer physicality were the wolf and the tortoise.  The tortoise was imagined as a kind of chilled out hippy, with a painted shell, round sunglasses and waistcoat.  The bright yellow colours and body language seemed to perfectly encapsulate the philosophy of doing things at your own pace that the tortoise represents.  Characters would frequently come down and walk amongst the audience during the action, so I got to see the tortoises costume close-up a few times.  It was covered in intricate graffiti and 60s designs, a lovely piece of costuming.  The tortoise was played by Noluthando Bogwana, who I also singled out in Philanthropists as being expertly expressive with her body language.  Her slow, shuffling tortoise walk is frequently played for laughs to great effect, particularly when she wins the race against the hare.  

The other favourite was the wolf.  The wolf was realised as a big, fat boxer.  Everything about the costume screamed false bravado.  The wolf is one of the 'bad guys' (such as they are) in this.  The character manages to be simultaneously scary and a figure of fun.  It's a nice tightrope to walk down, and the sheer physicality of the actor really helps.  Zamile Gantana is quite the imposing stage presence.  The guy is enormous, and the way his huge belly pokes out from under his overly tight athletic gear accentuates the theme of greed that his character represents, while also making his movements humorously clumsy. 

I also have to mention the 'lion'.  It makes a very brief appearance, but in its brief moment on stage is utterly awe-inspiring.  It comes at the end of a rhythmic dance number, and violently thrashes its straw mane violently around.  It then runs down the central aisle of the theatre.  I was sitting on this aisle, and there was a fantastic rush of wind and swoosh of straw as it flew past me.  It was a sudden, shocking tactile sensation that I wasn't expecting in the slightest. 

Every Isango Ensemble production has had extremely strong African themes running through it.  The instrumentation here was provided by xylophones and percussion was from upturned steel bins.  Part of the performance was in an African language, and I'm ashamed to say that I don't know what it was (possibly Zulu?). Even though I'm ignorant as to what was being said, the shift in language did a great deal for the production.   While the origins of Aesop's Fables is Greek, the African cultural influences made it feel more like these were extensions of the Anansi tales.  I always feel a little culturally illiterate when I'm confronted with influences outside of my cultural sphere, but if nothing else, it gives me the impetus to expand my horizons.

All three Isango productions have focussed on the downtrodden and dispossessed in society.  La boheme looked at starving artists, Philanthropists was about exploited workers and Aesop's Fables is no different. The overall plot is about a slave trying to free himself from his master.  This production may be targeted towards children, but explaining why freedom is important and the knowledge one must gain in order to be truly free is something adults and children alike can learn.  I really liked the themes of forgiveness too - when Aesop, the slave is finally free, he stops to emancipate his master who has been put in literal chains by his greed and hubris.  The dissolving of the boundaries between protagonist and antagonist reminded me of a Studio Ghibli film.  I think Disneyesque representations of black and white morality are a slightly dangerous lesson to drum into children, so teaching them that even the worst people can be redeemed and learn their lesson is a noble thing.

I've really enjoyed all of these productions, and I hope I can see them again at some point.   I've watched this company perform for maybe six hours in total over the last three weeks, and I've gained a great deal of respect for their talent, versatility and charisma.  They shook the audiences hands at the end of the performance, and I get a real sense of their warmth and enthusiasm for their art. My hat goes off to them.

© All articles copyright LONDON CITY NIGHTS.
Designed by SpicyTricks, modified by LondonCityNights